It’s the latter.
Derbyshire obviously has a strong personal interest in obfuscating the Asian threat to Whites, in promoting pro-Asian attitudes among Whites, and to make Whites accept Asians living amongst them. In addition, HBD is a radical political movement dedicated to enslaving Whites to Jews and Asians, and not let us not forget that Derbyshire is a prominent HBDer; thus, personal and ideological motivations are intertwined.
I’ve long attacked the “Arctic Alliance” nonsense, and I will do so again. You do not make alliances with deadly enemies who are bent on your destruction. The existential meaning of Asians is hatred of Whites – is that the foundation of a White-Asian alliance? Asians are part of the Rising Tide of Color invading White lands (“immigration”) and engaging in anti-White pan-colored activism once infested in White living spaces.
If Asians were really “allies” of Whites, then they would agree with the premise that Asians no more belong in, say, San Francisco, New York, Vancouver, etc. than the British belonged in Hong Kong. If Asians were “allies” then they would support the repatriation of Asian-“Americans” and Asian-“Canadians” and Asian-“Australians” and “British Asians” etc. back to their homelands. They would oppose Asian immigration to the West. But they do not do these things because the “Arctic Alliance” - just like HBD and “Silk Road White nationalism” – is nothing more than sugarcoated ruthless Asian imperialism.
Yes, Derbyshire says he doesn’t want an “Arctic Union” (except in his own household, which forces Asians into White living space), but note how he slyly equates a Euro-Asian union with an all Euro union. And this quibbling aside, my main point remains – the Asian “Arctics” (that of course include “Rosie”) are part of the anti-White colored alliance. Derbyshire can pontificate an opposition to the free flow of people across “Arctic” nations (while hypocritically facilitating it in his private life) but mass Asian immigration to the West is a fact. The Asian Invasion is ongoing and there can be no talk of an “alliance” until that ruthless invasion is stopped and then reversed through the repatriation of all persons of full or part Asian ethnic origins back to their homelands.